The High Cost of Social Media

by Mike Hanbery on June 25, 2010

in Business Social Media,Innovation,Marketing

In its 2010 Outlook Report, Razorfish explains why social media marketing requires a different approach from traditional adverting.

“Social media,” states the report, does not garner a huge share of media dollars.” 20 percent of the total 2009 digital ad spend was in ad networks, only four percent in social media. While a few ad networks include social media advertising as an option, it is a reasonable deduction that the social media buy within any network would be a small percentage.

Dude, social marketing is free.

No. Your Facebook account is free. Building a Page for your business is free. Social media ads are cheap (in part because the jury remains out on their value).

Strategic social marketing is not cheap because it is labor intensive. Effective social marketing costs good money.

Social changes the equation for advertisers.

Traditional advertising has a labor component but the great majority of expense comes from the advertising buy. A TV commercial or newspaper advertisement is designed once; the larger investment comes thereafter in location, location, location. Position and repetition, i.e. where and/or how often the ad is seen, is the more critical and costly metric. Even then, the media strategy is constructed and the buy negotiated once; then we launch, monitor, hope, track and adjust.

Not true for social. Designing an interactive campaign or even just a Page, managing a community, responding to comments and tweets and so on presents a much more intensive ongoing labor equation. Companies that carve out a separate section for social media or place it under the jurisdiction of customer acquisition or advertising rather than PR are demonstrating that they don’t get it.

Case Studies

Next Tuesday, I’ll do a quick comparison of two traditional advertising powerhouses integrating social to their mix. I love one and can’t seem to feel anything but pity for the other.

What are you noticing? Do you see advertisers doing things that make you shake your head or lean forward in your seat and say, “Hey, now there’s something…?”

Share

You might also like:

  1. Social Media Marketing: Who gets it and who doesn’t? Refresh is more interesting and sophisticated than, say, Honda’s lame...
  2. What Social Media Can’t Do for Your Business The more friends or followers to whom a user connects,...
  3. Social, Mobile and Email Marketing – An Integrated Customer Experience Part Two: The Mobile Opportunity The convergence of local, social and mobile has personalized advertising...
  4. The Evolution of Social Media for Business In and of itself, social media is not a disruptive...
  5. Job Search and Social Media Part III: Free Tools A job search is a marketing campaign, and as...
  • http://topsy.com/hanberymarketing.com/the-high-cost-of-social-media/?utm_source=pingback&utm_campaign=L2 Tweets that mention high-cost-of-social-media | Hanbery Marketing — Topsy.com

    [...] This post was mentioned on Twitter by mikehanbery, mikehanbery and mikehanbery, Socio Innovation. Socio Innovation said: RT Mike Hanbery: The High Cost of Social… http://goo.gl/fb/4eyYD socialmedia #businesssocialmedia #innovation #mar… http://bit.ly/bqRQTX [...]

  • Jim Nichols

    Thanks for the pluig Mike. Though I think you said things better than I did. ;-)

  • http://www.hanberymarketing.com/blog Mike Hanbery

    Jim, we're all trying to crack this nut together. BTW, cosmic moment: Just as this comment came in via Disqus I was sending a link to your blog http://www.nofunnylawyers.com/ to an audience member from my Qwest Business seminar yesterday who had a question about fair use and republishing of content from the Internet.

  • David

    Interesting article Mike, and very true. There are so many engaging viral videos, social media driven community projects and even some forums that are engaging for a company's customer base. This is significant viral pull already out there. It comes down to who is running the corporation and buying into a big leap of faith from their current point of view.

    We are long past the “Social Media is here to stay” phase, thou so many people are still writing blogs with that as their feature article title. It's like they are stuck on a wow factor from 7 years ago.

    We are into the strategy implementation stage. And just like brands can regress with actions like: making cars with brakes that disengage; put out cable commercials that completely turn off their market; or produce multi million dollar movies that are high on graphical wonders – low on writing skills; brands can also completely miss the advantages of social media that others are perfecting. And perfecting in clear view. Thank you for introducing us to Jim, I'll read his article now. :-)

  • http://www.hanberymarketing.com/blog Mike Hanbery

    David, yeah, I often wonder if we have reached critical mass with, “Social media is…” and, “Why it's important…” As you say, people write and speak on those subjects with pervasive proliferation, and I guess I'll leave them to it. When their audiences graduate to actually wanting get something from their efforts, we'll be here Swift Kickin'.

    If you read my post on TV advertising and social integration from 7.30.2010, and put a few minutes of thought to it, I'm sure you'll find it somewhere between comical and alarming the number of big advertisers who haven't acknowledged the shift. We think that about a third of all companies using social have a policy for its use and less than half have applied any sort of measurement criteria, and you know not all of those criteria are meaningful, so…we're still on the upward slope of the curve.

    Thanks for reading and for the insightful comment. Y'all come back soon, you hear?

  • http://www.searchengineoptimization.co.uk Bronte

    You have done good job, quality twitter followers are no doubt your most important followers. These are the ones who are actually following you to listen to what you have to say, asking questions, replying to your tweets but this type of followers a bit harder to gain but worth the work.

blog comments powered by Disqus

Previous post:

Next post: